Several analysts are debating whether spot Bitcoin ETFs are successfully attracting institutional capital. While total assets across Bitcoin ETFs dropped from a peak of $62 billion in June to $46 billion, they have rebounded by 30% since then. One Bloomberg analyst predicts institutional participation will double within a year, despite the current debate.
Bitcoin ETFs’ Initial Enthusiasm and Mixed Reactions
The launch of U.S. spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds in January was seen as a significant milestone for the cryptocurrency market. However, eight months later, opinions are divided. Some argue that the ETFs have failed to capture the attention of institutional investors, while others note a recent rebound in inflows, signaling institutional adoption.
Bianco’s Critique: Bitcoin ETFs as ‘Tourist Tools’
Jim Bianco, founder of Bianco Research, sparked controversy by claiming that Bitcoin ETFs have not lived up to their promise of attracting traditional finance investors. According to him, the ETFs have primarily been a tool for retail investors. He highlighted that total assets fell to $46 billion by September 9, with significant outflows led by traditional finance players.
Recent Rebound in Bitcoin ETF Inflows
Despite Bianco’s criticism, there has been a noticeable change in ETF performance. Starting from September 10, Bitcoin ETFs saw net inflows of over $568 million. As of September 23, daily inflows average $4.63 million, and cumulative inflows since January have reached $17.7 billion. This increase signals a growing confidence in Bitcoin from institutional investors, according to Bloomberg senior ETF analyst Eric Balchunas.
Bitcoin ETFs Show Strong Recovery
Although Bitcoin ETFs faced an initial decline, the recent influx of capital has propelled their assets under management toward record levels. On-chain holdings have grown by 30% to $59.2 billion, representing 4.6% of Bitcoin’s total market capitalization, according to Dune Analytics.
Debate Over Institutional Adoption of Bitcoin ETFs
Bianco remains critical, suggesting that institutional investors account for only a small portion of Bitcoin ETF holdings. He cites data showing that just 9% of Bitcoin ETF shares are held by wealth advisors, while 12% are owned by hedge funds. Bianco argues that 85% of ETF holders are not traditional finance players, emphasizing that the majority of inflows come from self-directed online accounts.
Analysts Disagree with Bianco’s Assessment
Many experts disagree with Bianco’s view. Juan Pellicer, a senior researcher at IntoTheBlock, challenges Bianco’s focus on dollar-based metrics, arguing that Bitcoin ETF demand has remained stable when measured in BTC terms. On-chain holdings of Bitcoin ETFs increased from 921,000 BTC at the beginning of August to over 933,000 BTC by mid-September, indicating steady accumulation despite fluctuating prices.
Hedge Funds’ Role in Bitcoin ETF Flows
Pellicer notes that hedge funds have played a significant role in driving Bitcoin ETF inflows through basis trading. He also highlights that major financial institutions, like Morgan Stanley, are slowly warming to the idea of Bitcoin ETFs. Under the right conditions, Pellicer expects to see more institutional capital flow into the products.
Bitcoin ETFs Outperform Expectations
Eric Balchunas, Bloomberg’s senior ETF analyst, maintains that Bitcoin ETFs have outperformed expectations, with net inflows of $16.8 billion between January and August. He downplays the significance of outflows, noting that only 1.5% of investors have exited their positions. Balchunas expects the number of institutional holders of BlackRock’s IBIT ETF to double within the next year, calling Bitcoin ETFs “freaks of nature.”
Institutional Adoption Set to Rise
Contrary to Bianco’s pessimism, other analysts believe Bitcoin ETFs are being adopted at a record pace. Matt Hougan, Chief Investment Officer at Bitwise Investments, notes that $1.45 billion has flowed into BlackRock’s IBIT ETF, with wealth advisors driving this surge. Hougan argues that Bitcoin ETFs are growing faster than any other ETFs launched in recent years.
Long-Term Outlook for Bitcoin ETFs
While the debate over Bitcoin ETFs’ success continues, there is agreement that institutional adoption is key to their future. Nicky Maan, CEO of Spectrum Markets, emphasizes the need for a regulated environment to foster mainstream adoption of digital assets. Meanwhile, Bianco sees 2028, after Bitcoin’s next halving, as the best time to attract traditional finance investors to Bitcoin ETFs.
The post Have Bitcoin ETFs Failed to Spur Institutional Adoption? appeared first on Cryptonews.
